TheSagaContinues

Thanks for the replies, great help.

So far we've been using the tried and true "Rule of Cool", and we apply any needed penalties as would be appropriate to the store.

It's nice to know your player is willing to work with you and not against you.

Oh, for sure. This is my regular play group, and they frequently give suggestions on things that are usually far worse than what I might've done. Like, one time they were rolling to pick a lock, and failed. The player whose character is the one actually doing it said, "Oh, great. And now I bet there are guard coming to deal with us."

Well, there sure is now.