12
« on: August 29, 2013, 04:41:46 pm »
While I'll mostly agree with you on your definition of state capitalism, I think you're forgetting one of the things that makes the People's Republic of China slightly communist as well as state capitalistic in their economy, which is that the businesses that dominate the Chinese economy are all state controlled. The Chinese government also controls all of the vital economic pillars in China such as energy resources, and heavy industry, while watching the development of other industries from behind the scenes. Mao's communism was more like fascism mixed with socialism, with some Chinese elements added in.
I don't count Cuba as a successful communist country because nearly everything is rationed, and society is VERY controlled, and combined with the fact Cuba is fairly isolated, I can't say for sure how successful Cuba truly is.
I'd hate to live in China, but I would love to visit it, to view some of the cultural and historical sights.
And while it's true that the Nazis liked animals, and were against smoking (and I'll admit, being Jewish, I might have some bias in my opinion), but I think Lenin wouldn't go as far as to commit genocide on a complete race of people. He'd kill a lot of people if needed, but never simply because of racial bias.
I also want to note that Scandinavia is also highly developed and hardly totalitarian. Seriously, their gun laws are some of the best in my mind. (You can get a submachine gun at age 18 in Sweden provided you have no criminal history, you have a background check, and you have a legitimate reason to own one.)
Lenin was brutal, but not nearly as paranoid as Stalin was. Lenin may have enacted the Purges, but I think he'd also have some limits.
Ah, Winston Churchill. His quotes are some of my favorite. My grandparents and my great-grandparents, who lived through World War 2, even the Scottish ones, always seemed to view him favorably (I'm have dual citizenship, both American and British).
One of my favorites is, "Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time." It reminds me of the USA's founding fathers' views that government is a necessary evil, albeit one they don't like.
And while the USSR and Nazi Germany's economies were fairly similar, there's still a difference in that the USSR was communist with the state control production and the economy by its own industries, Nazi Germany's economy was corporatism, where businesses were really closely involved with the state and their labor forces and were rewarded for successes, but were not outright controlled by the government. It's more that the businesses and industry were in close agreement in guiding the economy.